Have you ever noticed how some coffee tastes different than others? Some taste bright and fruity. Others taste deep and dark. Some taste like toasted graham crackers or dark chocolate-covered raisins or green tea. When it comes to drinking a cup of coffee, there’s a ton of stuff to unpack.
But the reason some coffee tastes more intense than others isn’t necessarily about the origin or the climate or how the beans are processed (although those factors certainly do play a part). The most pronounced flavor of the coffee is usually determined by how intensely the beans were roasted. Light and dark roasts are the first indicator as to what your coffee is going to taste like. So what’s the difference between dark and light roasts, anyway?
Smashed and Crispy Loaded Potatoes
Let’s start with a light roast. Light roasted coffee sees less heat than a dark roast. Heating coffee beans is like cooking any other ingredient: You’re essentially forcing water and moisture out of the bean by evaporation. Since light roasted beans aren’t left on the roasting machine for as long as dark roasted beans, they’re left with more moisture inside the bean, making it denser.
A denser coffee bean will give you more caffeine, more brightness (also referred to as “acid,” but not actually chemically acidic), and more fruit-forward, herbal flavors. There will be more going on in terms of complexity in a light roast coffee. But the body will actually be thinner than that of a dark roast, and will almost drink more like a strong black tea. And yes, the caffeine thing: If a serious coffee buzz is what you’re after, light roast is definitely the move.
Dark roast coffee beans stay on the roasting machine for a longer time or at a higher temperature. This means the beans will lose more moisture, making them less dense, less caffeinated, and more single-note in flavor. The complexities that light roast coffee start to disappear the longer you leave the beans on the roasting machine.
Photo by Chelsie Craig
If you like coffee that tastes like roasted nuts, caramel, and graham crackers, these are the coffee beans for you. Dark roast coffees taste how you think coffee tastes, reminiscent of an old-school diner cup, or what your parents make in the drip machine at home. And since the beans are roasted long enough to develop their oils and bring them to the surface, the body of your coffee will be thicker.
If you want to give your friends the crash course, you could paraphrase this whole thing by saying that light roast coffees have a thinner body and more delicate flavors. And dark roast coffees are more full-bodied with bolder, more straight-forward flavors. But that’s no fun. The best way to really understand the ins and outs of both light and dark roast is to take the time to brew a pot of each and figure out what you like more. But don’t think you have to pick a side. You can have your beans and drink them too.